Decorative Fireplace

The Best Wood Burning Fireplace Insert: Our Top Five Picks

Spread the Love
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

​Having a roaring fireplace during a cold winter's day is an excellent way to warm up or keep the living or bedroom cozy. It can also lend a romantic ambiance to a date or the celebration of a special anniversary. If you have an older fireplace, then buying the best wood burning fireplace insert may be the right solution for refurbishing your fireplace quickly. 

​Comparison Table

​BRANDS

DIMENSIONS OF INSERT

​BTU ​OUTPUT

ROOM COVERAGE

PRICING

​WARRANTY

​Napoleon 1402

​32 H x 42-inches W

​11, 500 up to 70,000 BTUs

​2,000 square feet

​From about $2,600 to $3,000

​Limited Lifetime

​Osburn 1600

​21 1/2 H x 24 1/8 W x 22-inches D

​Up to 65,000 BTUs

​1,600 square feet

​Around $1,600 to $2,100

​Lifetime

​Napoleon Timberwolf

​31 3/4 H x 44 7/16-inches W

​Up to 65,000 BTUs

​800 to 2,000 square feet

​About $2,000

​Limited Lifetime

IronStrike Montlake

​21 1/2 H x 25 W x 15 1/2-inches D

​Up to 76,000 BTUs

​1,200 to 2,200 square feet

​Under $2,200 to around $2,500

​Limited Lifetime

​IronStrike Legacy

​2 3/4 H x 30 1/2 W x 14 3/4-inches D

​Up to 79,000 BTUs

​Around 2,200 square feet

​From under $2,200 to $2,500

​Limited Lifetime

Wood Burning Insert FAQs

Wood burning inside the fireplace

​Image Source: Pixabay

Below are some of the most commonly asked questions about wood burning inserts. 

1. What is a wood burning insert?

A fireplace insert fits into an existing fireplace, whether it is brick or there is only a chimney without a fireplace.

2. How does a fireplace insert work?

Fireplace inserts can burn one of three fuels: wood, wood pellets, or gas. They install quickly and easily because they fit inside of an open fireplace, but first, it is vital that you make sure the flue works, and the chimney has a good lining. 

Many inserts include a chimney lining, so carefully read the information to save some money when you buy one. Also, it only costs about $150 to $165 to have professionals install an insert, which may include capping off a gas line and removing the damper or some bricks to fit the vent tube. 

Wood burning inserts have heavy duty doors that can protect the house from sparks or exploding wood when the fire is burning, so they are safer than using an open fireplace. They are also more energy efficient than open fireplaces due to their construction and, as a result, you’ll save money on your energy bills by installing and using one.

3. What is the cost of repairing a brick fireplace?

Many people install inserts because their brick fireplace needs repairs or replacing. If there are cracks in the fireplace, then they can be filled cheaply. It only costs about $200 to fix the cracks. However, if the fireplace needs repairs or replacing, it can cost anywhere from $1,000 to $10,000 depending on what needs repairing.

4. Where are wood burning inserts available?

Wood burning inserts are available for purchase at some home improvement stores like Home Depot or Lowe’s, at stores that sell fireplace accessories, inserts, wall-mounted or electric fireplaces, and online from eBay, Amazon, and websites that specialize in fireplaces and fireplace supplies. 

How We Reviewed

To find the best fireplace insert, we researched them to find the best brands and the sizes in which they are available. We also discovered how much square footage they can heat, and we read both reviews and testimonials from homeowners who own them. Then, after reviewing the information, we came up with this list of the best fireplace inserts.

Overall Price Range of Wood Burning Inserts

The price of an insert depends on the size that the homeowner needs and its options. An insert that can heat between 1,000 to 3,000 square feet can cost between $2,000 to $4,000.

Best Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Fireplace with a burning wood inside

​Image Source: Unsplash

This list of fireplace inserts is some of the best we found during our research.

No products found.

No products found.

A fireplace insert can make a brick fireplace more efficient when trying to add warmth to your home.

​KEY FEATURES

This Napoleon 1402 insert burns either wood logs or pellets for fuel to provide warmth for a living or bedroom that have a brick or rock fireplace. Most fireplaces are inefficient because the heat goes up through the chimney and never goes where it’s needed, into the room. 

The insert controls the disbursement of the heat with air blowers, and this Napoleon model has two fans that run quietly so that you could talk on the phone without disruption. The insert, along with the flashing, is black with black, almond, or green porcelain enamel finishes, and the top of the cast iron door looks elegant with its arched design. It has a shelf above the door for a tea kettle or Dutch oven.

The door has a full-view glass window that adds ambiance to the room. The insert, along with the flashing and trim measures 32 H x 42-inches W. The insert can put out about 11, 500 to 14, 500 BTUs, at high burn it can be as high as 70,000 BTUs, which is enough to heat rooms of 2,000 square feet. This insert is not suitable for a mobile home, and it needs a chimney liner.

WHERE TO BUY

Fireplace inserts are available online from eBay, Amazon, and the eFireplaceStore.com. It’s also available at brick and mortar retailers specializing in the sale of fireplaces, fireplace supplies, and accessories.

WARRANTY

Limited Lifetime Warranty

No products found.

No products found.

The Osburn company not only specializes in wood burning inserts, but they also make woodstoves.

​KEY FEATURES

This Osburn 1600 wood burning firebox is an efficient way to use your home’s fireplace. It fits into an opening in a brick or stone fireplace measuring 21 3/4 H x 26W x 14 ½-inches D. The over dimensions of the insert are: 21 1/2 H x 24 1/8 W x 22-inches D. It has a black metallic finish with a door made from cast iron.

The door has an adjustable handle with full-view glass with a system that can clean itself. There is also a blower that helps distribute the fire’s heat into the room, rather than up the chimney. It uses wood logs or pellets for fuel, but the logs can only be a maximum of 17-inches in length. The unit puts out up to 65,000 BTUs to heat a room that’s up to 1,600 square feet.

The six-inch vent pipe the unit needs is available separately, as is a door overlay, face place kit and faceplate trim. These items should be available from the retailer from where the customer purchases the insert.

WHERE TO BUY

​This fireplace insert is available from eBay, Amazon, Osburnwoodstoves.com, and eFireplaceStore.com and offline from fireplace and fireplace supply retailers.  

WARRANTY

​Lifetime warranty.

No products found.

No products found.

The Timberwolf Economizer is on the list as the best wood burning fireplace insert, and it's from the Napoleon company. 

​KEY FEATURES

This fireplace insert comes with the flashing, so it measures 31 3/4 H x 44 7/16-inches W. It has a black metal box with a black cast iron door. The flashing is adjustable at 1/4-inch increments to provide a minimum hearth depth of 14-inches. It fits in a fireplace opening of 22 H x 25 7/8 W x 14-inches D.

The insert has two blowers that circulate heat for about 800 to 2,000 square feet, and they both have automatic thermodiscs with speed control to make the room more comfortable during cold weather. It has a heat output of up to 65,000 BTUs. The door has a large ceramic glass opening that allows you to check on the fire safely.

The insert has approval from the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA. The firebox has a full refractory lining, and it fits logs up to 18-inches long. This insert will need a vent pipe with a six-inch opening.

WHERE TO BUY

​This insert is available from eBay, Amazon, eFireplaceStore.com, and individual fireplace and fireplace supply retailers offline.

WARRANTY

​Limited Lifetime Warranty

Montlake fireplace insert

​Image Source: ironstrike.us

This fireplace insert provides an efficient way to make your home cozy during a wintry or early spring day.

​KEY FEATURES

The IronStrike Montlake 230 insert can convert masonry fireplaces into a clean-burning, efficient wood burning fireplace. It is from IronStrike's Country Collection so that it would fit well in any home with a country décor and an empty fireplace. The insert consists of heavy gauge steel, a cast iron heat exchanger, and high-density firebricks that retain heat for more efficiency.

It has one blower with variable speeds that delivers the heat from the insert into the room. The Montlake provides up to 76,000 BTUs that can warm areas measuring about 1,200 to 2,200 square feet to keep family rooms warm on even the most bitter winter evenings. Buyers can choose a top warming area that is heavy gauge steel or cast iron.

There are also door options that can give the fireplace insert a decorative look. Buyers can choose nickel or brushed nickel door trim instead of black. The insert fits fireplaces as large as 21 1/2 H x 25 W x 15 1/2 -inches D, which can fit logs that are a maximum of 18-inches long. The door has ceramic glass that provides a full view of the interior, and it has an air wash system that keeps it clean. 

WHERE TO BUY

​The IronStrike Montlake 230 is available from eBay, firesideonline.com, and both online and offline retailers specializing in fireplaces and fireplace supplies.

WARRANTY

​Limited Lifetime Warranty 

Legacy fireplace

​Image Source: ironstrike.us

If the fireplace in your house doesn’t see much use because it doesn't provide enough heat, then this IronStrike insert can improve its efficiency.

​KEY FEATURES

With most fireplaces, the heat doesn't disperse well if there isn't a blower because it will go up the chimney. You'll end up spending more money on burning wood or pellets, and you'll still need to use the central heat to stay warm. However, fireplace inserts fit into most fireplaces snugly, and they have an enclosed design, with a blower, to distribute the heat evenly.

The Legacy puts out as much as 79,000 BTUs, which is more than most other insert models. The blower disperses the hot air from the firebox, and the sealed doorway, plus the afterburner tubes that create a secondary burn, makes for a very efficient, energy-saving fireplace. The insert can fit into fireplaces that are 22 3/4 H x 30 1/2 W x 14 3/4-inches D, which can hold logs up 22 1/2-inches long.

This unit can provide heat for areas as large as 2,200 square feet. The glass on the door offers an open view of the fire, and an air wash system keeps it clean. IronStrike has options for making the insert more aesthetically pleasing like doorways that are black, brushed metal or brushed nickel. The surrounds and trim are also available in black or nickel. 

WHERE TO BUY

​This IronStrike model is available from eBay, firesideonline.com, and both online and offline retailers specializing in fireplaces and fireplace supplies.

WARRANTY

​Limited Lifetime Warranty

​Final Verdict

Couple Sitting in fron of a fireplace

​Image Source: Unsplash

If your home has a fireplace you've been unable to enjoy, then a fireplace insert can allow you to use it once again. After researching them for this review, we concluded that the Osburn 1600 was the best wood burning fireplace insert for most homes. It can keep an area of 1,600 comfortable when it's cold outside, and it is one of the lowest price inserts from this list.

Also, homeowners who have it are happy with this product. One customer has had theirs for over 20 years and says it is still working very well. If you need to improve your fireplace’s efficiency, consider installing one of these wood burning inserts.

​Featured Image Source: Pixabay


Spread the Love
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: