Want the old-fashioned charm of a wood burning stove and the cleanness and efficiency of a modern heater? The best pellet stove can give you the best of both worlds.
Since they come in lots of styles, sizes, price ranges, and feature sets, you’ll have lots to choose from. But how do you choose the right one? We’ve reviewed 10 top models with an array of features to help you narrow things down.
We also talk about what features to look for so you you can pick the best pellet stove for you.
How We Chose Our Ratings For The Best Pellet Stove
To us, accuracy and honesty go hand in hand. And they are by far the most important factors when it comes to choosing our ratings and which products make it on the list. We go by customer reviews, features of the products, and how well each company delivered its promises to their customers. All of this is to give you, the buyer. The best options as well as the trust you need to decide on peace.
So, here is our handpicked selection of the best pellet stoves.
Top 10 Best Pellet Stove Comparison Table
Here’s Our Full Reviews Of The 10 Best Pellet Stoves
Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22
- Requires Ventilation and Heats up to 2,800 sq. feet
- Large viewing area - Bay Design - Carbon Black!
- Powerful Blower. 110 Volt. Easy to clean. NOT VENTLESS
The Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22 is perfect for large viewing areas and is able to heat up to 2,000 square feet. It also boasts a powerful blower that makes 86% of the heat it produces extremely efficient, as well as EPA certification.
The features it contains includes a 55-pound hopper capacity, automatic ignition, ash pan to ensure maximum cleanliness, and a programmable thermostat. Also, the customer service is perfect for this product. It comes with a one-year parts warranty, as well as assistance with any technical problems or confusions that you may have after purchasing.
Pros
- 50,000 btu – Heats up to 2,800 sq. feet
- Large viewing area
- Powerful Blower, 86% Burn efficiency, EPA Certified, 110 Volt
Cons
- With power use only
Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove
- Reinvent the way you heat your home with Castle's Serenity wood pellet stove and new Smart Controller
- The Smart Controller allows you to choose manual, thermostat, and weekly operational modes to heat your home on your schedule. Along with calendar and time based heating options, you can also set a local thermostat or manually set it on one of five burn levels
- The thermostat feature will quickly heat your space to your desired temperature. Once the desired temperature has been reached, the stove will turn to its lowest setting to maintain a comfortable space.
Coming in second is the Castle 12327, rated number 1 for value by ReviewLab.com.
Something incredible about the Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet is that it comes with a smart controller. The smart controller allows you to use a remote to control many of the stove’s functions, such as the manual, thermostat, and operational modes on which you want to heat your home. It also can heat on your personal schedule made with your controller. Additionally, the stove has a total of 5 heat levels, the fifth being the highest. You can also choose which level you want your heat on with the controller. Plus, this stove is very easy to keep clean and maintain. With no tubes or corrugations, it is very easy to clean.
Pros
- Easy Installation
- Programmable Controller
- High Efficiency
Cons
- stove can’t be hand-stoked if the electricity goes out
US Stove GW1949 Wiseway Non-Electric Pellet Stove
- EPA-certified nonelectric pellet stove utilizes a Natural gravity feed system, for less maintenance
- 40,000 BTUs heats up to 2,000 sq. Ft
- Uses standard 3-inch pellet venting
This EPA-certified stove has a feature that the others haven’t had yet: it is non-electric. To avoid using electricity, this pellet stove uses a natural gravity feed system. Which not only brings down your electric bill, but also provides for easy maintenance. Like the first pellet stove, the US Stove GW1949 is perfect for large areas and spaces, as it is able to heat up to 2,000 square feet. Its other unique features include a 3-inch venting, 60-pound hopper that lasts for 36 hours. And can run completely silent, making it more ideal than others for a bedroom or quiet office space.
Pros
- Silent operation and Modern Style
- 40,000 BTUs heats up to 2,000 sq. Ft
- Uses standard 3-inch pellet venting
Cons
- Epa-certified nonelectric pellet stove
No products found.
No products found.
This stove has something the other 3 don’t: it is cabinet style. However, although it might seem small, this heater can heat up to an astounding total of 2,200 square feet, making it perfect for big rooms like kitchens and dining rooms. Furthermore, it can burn for up to 70 hours. Something else that makes this stove stand out from the rest is that not only is it EPA certified. But also has received an 85% efficiency rating. Like the third pellet stove, this one also has 5 heat level settings. It also has an automatic light ignition and an exclusive Comfort Control System that allows you to choose whether you want it to run continuously on either MIN or MAX.
Pros
- Reduce heat or cool air loss by 90 percent
- Cabinet-style doors with mesh panels
- 9-panel smoked .1875-inch tempered safety glass
Cons
- Doors open completely for full-view
No products found.
No products found.
Fifth on the list is the Pelpro Pellet Stove. This stove can also heat a ton of space like the Pleasant Hearth one, heating up to 2,200 square feet. It also boasts an extra-large hopper of 130 pounds and an 85% efficiency rating. Additionally, this stove beats the Pleasant Hearth’s record of 70 hours. The Pelpro Pellet Stove can burn for up to 80 hours straight on three different heat settings.
Pros
- High-efficiency operation
- Extremely reliable technology
- Automatic ignition
Cons
- Runs itself
No products found.
No products found.
Next up is the US Stove 4840 Wall Mount Direct Vent Pellet Heater. This pellet heater, unlike any of the rest, is a wall mounted heater. Meaning you can place this heater anywhere on your walls. It is able to heat up to 1,000 square feet and features automatic ignition. As well as diagnostic controls with a 5 level heat setting. The heater is able to heat for up to 24 hours, but only on the low setting. If you have it put on high for the entire time, it can heat for up to 6 hours. All of this is done with a 28-pound hopper capacity. Something else that is unique about this heater is that it comes with a vent kit. This kit includes a mounting bracket, stove adapter, cap, wall thimble, vent attachment, and a Twist lock pipe. This all makes installation a much more doable task.
Pros
- Automatic ignition and diagnostic controls
- Easy to access for cleaning and maintenance
- 28-Pound Hopper capacity provides up to 24 hours
Cons
- For a workshop or small living space only
No products found.
No products found.
This pellet stove has a total of 65,000 BTU’s that give it the ability to heat up to an outstanding 2,800 square feet. Something that is interesting about this stove is that it is completely automatic, thanks to auto-ignition and a variety of different electronic controls. Additionally, it has a 120-pound pellet capacity. And finally, two more unique things that set the Vogelzang Pellet Stove out from the crowd is its LED display with the thermostat as well as the air wash glass.
Pros
- Fully automatic pellet stove with auto ignition
- 120 lb. Pellet capacity
- easy-to-use electronic controls
Cons
- Air wash glass
No products found.
No products found.
This pellet stove is similar to the Castle Serenity wood pellet stove, and it also comes with a similar controller. With the controller, you can put your heater on either D1, D2, D3, or D4 mode to determine the kind of heat you want and when you want it, also with 4 different heat levels. With an exhaust pipe of just 3 inches, this wood pellet stove is also extremely easy to clean. This heater is excellent for smaller spaces, however, as it only heats to about 431-646 square feet.
Pros
- Experience affordability, style, and practicality
- Smart Controller has four burn levels
- Serenity Stove is designed to be easy to clean
Cons
- Electronic consumption: 100-400W/H,Voltage 110~120 Volts
No products found.
No products found.
This pellet stove is fully insulated with internal ducting that ensures you are getting maximum heat transfer and maximum efficiency. With five blower speed settings, his stove burns wood pellets, corn, soybeans, cherry pits, olive pits, and other compressed biomass fuels. Additionally, the stove has been verified safe and approved for mobile homes and modular ones.
Pros
- Fully Insulated internal ducting
- Five blower speed settings
- Approved for mobile and modular homes
Cons
- Installation materials are not included
No products found.
No products found.
The tenth pellet burner is the US Stove 5500M King Pellet Burner, which also comes with an igniter. The stove comes with 5 heat level settings like many of the others. And a 120 CFM blower that gives automatic circulation, resulting in an evenly spread heat. Something unique about it is that it also comes with a digital control board that allows you to adjust the heat. And other settings right from it by simply pushing a button, plus an LED display.
Here’s A Relevant Video From YouTube:
Pros
- 5 heat settings
- 120 CFM blower with automatic circulation
- List Element
Cons
- Materials for installation are NOT Included
The Best Pellet Stove Buyer’s Guide
So, out of all ten pellet stoves, which one is the right for you? There is no perfect product, but there are definitely certain key features that you want to look for before making your final decision on which one to purchase. Out of all the ten pellet stoves, the one with the best customer rating is the Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22. Which came in on the list as number one.
Features to Consider
However, each product differs in the kinds of features it contains and the abilities it offers, such as remote controls, number of heat level settings, and easy maintenance. When looking for the perfect pellet stove, however, I would say that it is most important to think in the long term. Is this a stove that will work for you again next season? How long has it lasted for other customers? Overall, is it durable?
How Stuff Works advises that you consider the following factors.
- The square footage of your home or the room you wish to heat. You’ll need 5,000 Btu for every 200 square feet of space.
- EPA certification: The best pellet stove is one that’s certified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Even if air quality and the environment aren’t issues for you, local laws often require this.
- Your design preferences: Of course you’ll want to pick a model that looks good in your home and goes with your decor. If you want it to look like a fireplace, get a pellet stove with a viewing window.
- Hopper size: Want to light it and forget it for the rest of the day? if so, the best pellet stove for you is one with a large hopper.
- Your flooring: Because pellet stoves burn hot, some types of flooring aren’t safe.
Cold Season
Most likely, you are choosing to buy a pellet stove because it is the cold season. Which means that this time next year. You will be in the same situation…unless you invest in the right pellet stove for you.
If you are planning to use the stove for a small room or an office or workspace. Your best choice would probably be something like the Landove NextStep Serenity Wood Pellet Stove. Which gives you a lot of awesome features, and only heats 431-646 square feet.
So, all in all, the perfect stove for you depends on your use and your priorities.
